Read the case study presented at the end of Chapter 11, You Be the Judge, which begins, “During an unexpected heat wave,…” (Guido, p. 195):
- What provisions of an insurance policy would you consult to determine if an insurance company should pay such a claim, and what would the limits of the liability be?
- Is the nursing home insurance company correct in saying that this is a professional judgment issue?
- Which insurance company (the nursing home’s or that of the administrator of the nursing home, assuming she has coverage) should pay the court-ordered judgment?
- How would you decide the case?
Please combine all of these responses into a single Microsoft Word document for submission. Submit only completed assignments (not partial or “draft” assignments). Be thorough in your responses to adequately address all aspects of each question.
Submit only the assignments corresponding to the module in this section.
Assignment Expectations
Length: 700 words; answers must thoroughly address the questions in a clear, concise manner.
Structure: Include a title page and reference page in APA style. These do not count towards the minimum word count for this assignment.
References: Use the appropriate APA style in-text citations and references for all resources utilized to answer the questions. Include at least three (3) scholarly sources to support your claims.
Format: Save your assignment as a Microsoft Word document (.doc or .docx).
File name: Name your saved file according to your first initial, last name, and the assignment number (for example, “RHall Assignment 1.docx”)
Expert Solution Preview
Insurance policies typically outline the terms and conditions under which an insurance company should pay a claim and the limits of their liability. In the given case study, the provisions of an insurance policy that could be consulted to determine if the insurance company should pay such a claim would include coverage for unexpected heat waves or extreme weather conditions, coverage for potential damage or harm caused by heat waves, and any specific exclusions or limitations related to such events. These provisions would help determine if the claim falls within the scope of coverage and if the insurance company should be liable for compensating the affected party.
Regarding the limits of liability, insurance policies often specify the maximum amount the insurance company is obligated to pay in the event of a claim. This amount is typically outlined as a coverage limit. It is crucial to consult the insurance policy to determine the specific liability limits for different types of claims and damages. This information would be important in assessing the extent to which the insurance company should be responsible for compensating the affected party in this particular case.
The nursing home insurance company’s claim that this is a professional judgment issue may have some merit. Professional judgment refers to the exercise of discretion and decision-making skills by professionals based on their expertise and knowledge. In the given case, if the decision to evacuate or implement appropriate measures during the heat wave was indeed a professional judgment issue, it would imply that the nursing home’s staff had the responsibility to make decisions based on their professional training and judgment. In this context, it would be essential to explore the specific terms and conditions of the insurance policy to determine if professional judgment issues fall within the scope of coverage and liability for the insurance company.
Determining which insurance company should pay the court-ordered judgment would depend on the terms and conditions specified in the insurance policies of both the nursing home and the administrator. It would be necessary to thoroughly review both policies to ascertain the scope of coverage and the specific circumstances under which each insurance company would be responsible for compensating the court-ordered judgment. If the insurance policy of the nursing home covers liabilities arising from the administrator’s actions, it could potentially be liable for the court-ordered judgment. However, if the administrator has separate coverage under her policy, the responsibility to pay the court-ordered judgment would likely fall on her insurance company.
Deciding the case would require a comprehensive analysis of all relevant factors, including the insurance policies, the specific provisions, and limitations outlined in each policy, and the applicable laws and regulations. It would also be essential to consider any relevant precedents, if applicable, that could guide the decision-making process. Additionally, expert opinions and testimonies from medical professionals, legal experts, and insurance specialists could provide valuable insights to aid in making an informed decision. Ultimately, the decision would be based on a thorough evaluation of the evidence and legal considerations to ensure a fair and just outcome.
In conclusion, determining the provisions of an insurance policy that apply, the limits of liability, and which insurance company should pay the court-ordered judgment requires a careful examination of the specific terms and conditions outlined in the insurance policies involved. The nursing home insurance company’s claim of professional judgment issue and the administrator’s insurance coverage would also need to be taken into account. The final decision would be made based on a comprehensive assessment of all relevant factors, legal considerations, and expert opinions.
