To complete this peer review you will: a) Read your fellow students’ papers, b) Identify the 3 most significant issues/weaknesses in your peer’s paper, and

To complete this peer review you will:

a) Read your fellow students’ papers,

b) Identify the 3 most significant issues/weaknesses in your peer’s paper, and

c) For each issue/weakness, provide constructive criticism using this formula (and using the table below and the slides in the Final research paper section for help):

– Identify the problem,

– Explain why it is a problem, and

– Provide a concrete solution for the problem.

You can use point form in providing your feedback, but you need to be clear.

Procedure

Purpose

Examples

Identifying

To search for problematic areas

“Do you realize that … and … are incompatible?”

“It sounds to me that this issue you presented is too subjective.”

“It seems to me that … and … should not be compared in this dimension.”

Explaining

To describe the nature of problems

“You may be wrong here because …”

“This example may not be suitable to illustrate the idea of the topic sentence.”

“This quote may not be relevant to what you are discussing. You should say … instead.”

Giving suggestions

To provide workable suggestions for modifications

“Why don’t you change the idea from … to …?”

“I think you should give more information about … in the second-last paragraph?”

“You might use the word … rather than …”

“You need to add a phrase concerning the disadvantages of … here.”

Share This Post

Email
WhatsApp
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Reddit

Order a Similar Paper and get 15% Discount on your First Order

Related Questions

The whole assignment is explained thoroughly on the attached file. My research topic for which i need annotated bibliography is “How can integrated mental

The whole assignment is explained thoroughly on the attached file. My research topic for which i need annotated bibliography is “How can integrated mental health and addiction treatment programs improve outcomes for individuals with co-occurring substance use disorders and mental illness?” Just make the best possible assignment based on what

Writing Researchable Research Questions & Creating Valid Measures Homework Form a research question, research hypothesis, and null hypothesis from the

Writing Researchable Research Questions & Creating Valid Measures Homework Form a research question, research hypothesis, and null hypothesis from the variables provided. Once complete, be sure you identify which variable is the independent variable and which is the dependent variable. Next create a conceptualization for each variable and provide at

Module 1: Discussion 1 For this synchronous Discussion, you will create a narrated PowerPoint or  PechaKucha presentation. If you are interested in

Module 1: Discussion 1 For this synchronous Discussion, you will create a narrated PowerPoint or  PechaKucha presentation. If you are interested in learning more about PechaKucha, review the PechaKuchaLinks to an external site. website titled Visual Storytelling That Celebrates Humanity. Also, review the video How to Make a Presentation With PechaKuchaLinks to an

Assignment: What Early Childhood Professionals Need to Know About Contemporary Families and Why Today’s families share many similar characteristics but

Assignment: What Early Childhood Professionals Need to Know About Contemporary Families and Why Today’s families share many similar characteristics but differ significantly in a wide assortment of others. As an early childhood professional working with young children and their families, what do you need to know about contemporary families that

Before completing this assignment, please review the Full Research Paper and Assignments 1-3 General Instructions. You will also need to complete the

Before completing this assignment, please review the Full Research Paper and Assignments 1-3 General Instructions. You will also need to complete the following modules:- Introduction- Writing Style and Appropriate Citations- Title, Abstract & Formatting.For Assignment #1, you will submit a draft of your title page, abstract, and introduction portions of your your

ADDIE: Phase Two Lesson Plan Two: Integrating Technology/Media within Concept Attainment Mapping Lesson Concept Attainment Model – Integrating

ADDIE: Phase Two Lesson Plan Two: Integrating Technology/Media within Concept Attainment Mapping Lesson Concept Attainment Model – Integrating Technology/Media within Concept Mapping Lesson In this technical assignment, you will use the Concept Attainment Model to plan a lesson that integrates technology/media resources. You will integrate concept mapping into the lesson. A

Overview of Instructional Design Reference: Kilbane, C. & Milman, N. (2014). Teaching models: Designing instruction for 21st century learner. Upper Saddle

Overview of Instructional Design Reference: Kilbane, C. & Milman, N. (2014). Teaching models: Designing instruction for 21st century learner. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson. ISBN 978-0-205-60997- It is critical that you gain an understanding of the difference between instructional design models and the models used for instruction/lesson planning. The purpose